IRS Must Make Those Confusing Math-Error Notices Easier To Understand

A new law hopes to put an end to confusing tax notices from the IRS.

getty

Tired of confusing IRS notices? You could see a difference in some notices, thanks to the Internal Revenue Service Math and Taxpayer Help Act (H.R. 998), which was signed into law this month. The new law has been widely praised by the National Taxpayer Advocate as a long-overdue step toward clearer and fairer IRS communication with taxpayers.

The IRS MATH Act requires the IRS to change the format of millions of “math-error” notices. Although these notices are meant to handle simple errors quickly, they have often been characterized as vague and confusing. The result is that many taxpayers have struggled to understand exactly what the IRS changed on their tax return, or how to contest it.

The new law fixes those problems by requiring the IRS to explain exactly what the agency thinks is wrong, why it made the adjustment, and what rights the taxpayer has to challenge that action.

Math Errors

Math-error notices are authorized under section 6213(b) of the Tax Code, which allows the IRS to immediately assess additional tax without going through the normal deficiency process. By law, that shortcut is allowed only for simple, obvious mistakes—math errors, using the wrong line of the tax table, missing or mismatched Social Security numbers, inconsistent entries between forms, or missing required schedules and forms.

The authority does not apply to more complex issues, like verifying whether it’s appropriate to claim dependents, determining whether business expenses can be supported, or determining stock basis. A quick rule of thumb: If the issue requires interpretation, investigation, or document review, it is not a math error. Those matters must follow the standard audit and deficiency procedures.

If you disagree with a math-error adjustment, you have 60 days to ask the IRS to reverse it. Missing that deadline generally means the assessment becomes final and you lose the right to appeal to the Tax Court. After that, the only path forward is to pay the tax, submit a claim for refund, and, if necessary, file a refund suit in either the U.S. district court or the U.S. Court of Federal Claims.

For years, the National Taxpayer Advocate has warned that these notices often fail to clearly explain the issue—and may even leave out the 60-day deadline information altogether. That means that that taxpayers might note be aware of the right to appeal or what steps to take. The Advocate has repeatedly stressed that clarity and transparency are essential to protecting due process. The goal of the new bill is to allow taxpayers to know what the IRS changed and why.

How The Bill Became Law

H.R. 998 (now Public Law No. 119-39) answers these concerns directly. The bill was introduced in the House in February 2025 by Rep. Randy Feenstra (R-Iowa) and Rep. Brad Schneider (D-Ill.), with Sens. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) and Bill Cassidy (R-La.) leading the effort in the Senate. The measure quickly gained broad bipartisan support. The House passed the bill by voice vote, and the Senate approved it unanimously, moving it to the President’s desk where it was signed into law.

What The Law Says

Under the new law, math-error notices must be much clearer and more specific. Each notice must describe the type of error, cite the relevant tax code provision, and identify the exact line or schedule on the return that is impacted. The notice must also explain any adjustments made to the return, including changes to adjusted gross income, taxable income, deductions, credits, and tax liability.

How specific will the notice be? According to the Taxpayer Advocate, instead of a vague message like “There is an error in your Recovery Rebate Credit,” a notice must now say something like: “We adjusted line 30 of your Form 1040 because our records show you already received the full Recovery Rebate Credit amount for which you were eligible. As a result, you are not entitled to claim an additional credit.”

To help taxpayers understand important deadlines, the 60-day window to request abatement or challenge the IRS’s determination must be shown in the notice in bold, size 14 font, immediately next to the taxpayer’s address on the notice’s first page.

The notice must also include IRS contact information.

And, importantly, if the IRS takes action, it must issue a follow-up notice that explains what happened in plain language and provides an itemized computation of the adjustments.

Pilot Program

To make sure taxpayers actually receive these time-sensitive letters, the law also creates a pilot program requiring some math-error notices to be sent by certified or registered mail (the idea is that sending mail by certified or registered mail conveys a sense of urgency). The pilot program should begin in the next 18 months. To track the progress, the law requires the IRS to report to Congress on the pilot program’s impact.

What’s Next

Clearer notices are expected to reduce confusion and anxiety, making it more likely that taxpayers will respond. That’s the good news.

But don’t expect to see a change overnight. The new law gives the IRS has 12 months to make the changes. With a skinnier IRS in place and a potentially complicated tax season in the cards, most tax practitioners don’t expect the agency to act quickly.

ForbesIRS Has Significant Backlogs Following The Shutdown: What’s Moving And What’s Still StuckBy Kelly Phillips ErbForbesWatchdog Finds 2025 Tax Filing Season Was A Success, Worries About 2026By Kelly Phillips Erb

Source: https://www.forbes.com/sites/kellyphillipserb/2025/12/03/new-law-requires-irs-to-make-those-confusing-math-error-notices-easier-to-understand/